Every month, leadership teams approve budgets for customer acquisition with a single expectation: growth. They watch the traffic, track the clicks, and trust that more audience reach translates to enterprise value. What they often fail to notice is how much of that capital is quietly lost to platform-reported activity that never actually reaches the bottom line.
I am Josh, and welcome back to the City Shift Finance podcast.
Our guest today is Jeff Swartz, the founder and CEO of Qujam, a self-serve geofenced advertising platform. He has held roles at CBS Television and the Levenson Group, and brings over two decades of front-line media industry experience to the conversation.
He is also an adjunct professor in the Palumbo-Donahue School of Business at Duquesne University and the author of the Amazon number one best seller, The Intentional Leap: Lessons and Learnings for Newer Entrepreneurs.
Today we are looking at where advertising dollars actually go, how customer acquisition decisions get made, and what separates organizations that spend with precision from those that spend with hope.
In an era where algorithms decide who sees your brand, relying on broad, rented strategies is no longer just inefficient; it is a direct threat to your margin. We will cover where the waste actually lives, how hyper-targeted local technology is changing the field, and why the human decision layer remains the most important part of any digital system.
Jeff, welcome to the show: Most businesses spend on average most businesses spend on advertising every month.
-Where do you think the largest amount of advertising waste actually occurs?
Jeff: The Root Causes
When it comes to advertising waste and where I think that it actually occurs, there's really two key areas in my opinion to look at. The first one being the root cause of waste and the second one being the point of waste itself. So I'm going to break those down in pretty good detail and I'm going to start with the root causes which the root causes are going to be either at the planning phase or at the optimization phase.
So to dive into the planning phase, it makes a lot of sense. The game plan that you have for your advertising is going to be the foundation that you build everything upon. Having a really good game plan means a really good foundation. If you have a rushed plan or a uninformed plan, then it can actually result in a significant amount of waste. So my recommendations are to make sure that you have dedicated enough time, resources, budget, and data in order to efficiently assess your game plan and develop it.
Another mistake that I see in the game plan phase is that you kind of rinse and repeat from last year or you create one game plan. Do multiple scenarios that are based off of real first and third party data. The first party data should be what you collect whether you're a new business or 100-year old business. You will have data to collect and analyze. That is your data to assess at the sales point, at the advertising point, the marketing points as well too, as well as third-party data that you can literally find online. You can hire a third party resource, get information from systems, a bunch of different areas.
So you want to have a lot of information, but you also want to make sure that you're focusing on the KPIs, your key performance indexes. So assessing what data is actually important to you in order to compile it for your game plan to say, okay, let's run these scenarios. I have game plan A, game plan B, game plan C. Looking at the data points, what do I think I'm going to achieve data-wise? impressions, clicks, sales, uh, leads, all those different kind of components that you can put into it with game plan A versus B versus C. What makes the most sense logically?
The other thing that you have to do is you have to be very comfortable with the fact that you are not going to create the perfect game plan to begin with. That's where optimization comes into play. And having good optimization plan really helps ensure that you can have a good foundation built, but you know that you're going to make it better. So that said, start with a really strong game plan by dedicating time, resources, energy, and doing multiple scenarios to help minimize waste.
And then in the optimization phase, you need to have a structured optimization schedule. How often do you look at things? How often do you review things? As a business owner, you have to understand and educate yourself on the information that you're digesting. And then where I found a lot of waste comes into play is if you try to optimize and change things too quickly where you don't have enough information. You haven't given the campaigns enough time to really um start performing for yourself or if you give it too much time and you don't optimize or you make wrong optimizations based off of not understanding your data or you have enough data and you just don't do anything with it.
So those are the two areas of waste that I would say that you should address the uh from the cause of waste right from the point of waste like where you're actually wasting your dollars. I would say nowadays there's kind of two camps is there's going too broad with your targeting and your advertising which doesn't work for most SMBs uh because they usually have a more narrow audience uh or you're going too narrow which going too narrow is kind of like going spear fishing. You're either going to hit something and eat well or you're going to miss and you're not going to eat at all. Right?
So, there's something called integrated marketing communications that I've kind of adapted into a theory that I called the spiderweb effect. And I have an article on this as well, too, if anybody's interested. But the spiderweb effect allows you to visualize all the different targeting mediums and creative that you're using in your advertising as threads of a spiderweb. And if you have strong threads and multiple of them that are all intertwined, you're going to create a reinforced web that's hard to miss, but also hard to get out of.
The problem is you get into waste whenever you have really strong threads that are only a handful of them where they're intertwined, but there's a lot of holes that the target audience can get through. Or a problem is you have really weak threads and there's a lot of them, but then you create a flimsy spiderweb that's kind of hard to not get out of and doesn't really convert uh for you that well.
So, I like that kind of visualization to be able to identify, do I have a good holistic game plan in place and am I going too broad or too narrow or do I have a good mix of these things where it creates a spiderweb that's strong and stable and able to work really well for me. So, try not to go too broad, try not to go too narrow and um uh 100%. and then try to mix those things together so you have a good reach and a good frequency and a good targeting to minimize waste to your specific audience as well too.
Josh: The Planning Problem
A plan is only as strong as the data that informs it, and an average margin can easily mask deep structural inefficiencies. When leadership relies on a single, rigid marketing plan, they are essentially guessing. The spiderweb effect Jeff describes is a valuable perspective because it highlights that customer acquisition is not a single transaction; it is a network of interconnected touchpoints. If your threads are weak or disconnected, your capital simply slips through the gaps.
Accessing hyper-targeted technology has historically required working through intermediaries, agencies and vendors that introduced high minimums, steep markups, and managed services that kept the business at a distance from its own data. Jeff built QJam specifically to close that gap.
Jeff, what operational problem did you see in the agency world that made you decide to build QJam as a self-served platform?
When One Plan Meets Reality
Chart
When One Plan Meets Reality
Share of marketing budget consumed by each structural failure cause, versus capital that reached intended channels.
47 cents of every marketing dollar is wasted on average. Multi-scenario planning built on first- and third-party data reduces that figure by eliminating the structural causes before the budget is committed.
Source: City Shift Finance · Improvado 2026 · Layer Five Nov 2025
Illustrative scenario based on published industry data as of May 2026
Jeff: Six Closed Doors
I really enjoy talking about the origins of Qujam and why it is a self-served platform as a primary focus and exactly kind of what the gap in the market was that I feel like QJam is trying to fit because that's exactly what it is. It's intended to be a tool that's solving a problem that a lot of people were having and always had this kind of rob from the rich, give to the poor, Robin Hood kind of feel of giving technology that people wanted but weren't really getting access to to the level that they were desiring.
Before I do that, I guess I should probably tell you what geofencing is. So geo fencing is taking satellite uh information, GPS information, and identifying that somebody's been at a very specific location, mainly off of their mobile devices. And then after identifying that someone's been at competitor's building, let's say, or a nearby restaurant or whatever it might be, a very specific location, we're able to serve them display ads, OTTC TV ads, which is like Hulu, video pre-roll ads or uh digital audio ads, uh to any of those devices that are connected to that original device for the next 30 days. So, that's a quick down and dirty overview of geofencing.
I got into it because my ad agency that I owned was specifically focused on hyper-targeted digital advertising and geofence advertising was a big part of what we were doing. We got known for it. We became a thought leader on it. We also created some partnerships that we were ending up getting I I'm not even exaggerating hundreds of leads every single year. And what I realized is our agency wasn't the right fit for the majority of them. But I also realized that other vendors and other agencies were also not the right fit for what people were looking for as well too.
And that's where I kind of came up with these what I call six closed doors of geofencing. And it seemed like not that it seemed like it it it appears that every option out there for geofencing has at least six of these doors closed. And those doors are either they have high minimums. My ad agency had minimums um not super high but high enough for people to be deterred that just wanted to try geo fencing. They had high cost per thousands or rates. Uh a lot of that uh uh revolved around the fact that you know small budgets meant that the person running the campaigns needed to take a lot higher margins. So their rates kind of went up so they could actually afford to pay for the person pulling the levers and any other infrastructure in place.
The third one is managed service. People did not want to have somebody else managing it for them. A lot of times a lot of people do. They don't want to worry about it, but there's a huge population that was like, I want to be in control. I just want to go on. I want to set my fences. I want to see my information. I want to be able to run my own campaigns.
The fourth one is that some places didn't have reporting dashboards. Many places did, but not all of them. And a lot of times they would send out uh like Excel spreadsheets maybe once a month or even more often than that, but still not as useful as a actual live reporting dashboard at your fingertips.
And the last two are going to be that a lot of people want to pay with credit card for understandable reasons and not have an upcharge on it. And they wanted to be on the superior technology. They didn't want to be on technology that wasn't proven. They didn't want to be on technology that maybe wasn't an industry leader as well too.
So what Qujam does is it opens up all those doors. Every single one of these doors was intentionally opened by the QJam platform because we identified that these are the things that are the hurdles that people were complaining about. And that's where the market fit was. That's where the gap in the market was. And it was a hunch that I ended up having a good year uh at that agency and said, "I'm going to invest in it." Because after 2 years of looking around waiting for somebody that I could refer to to be able to do these things for people, I realized no one was really kind of stepping up that plate. So I said, "All right, let's do it. Let's create a QJam." And uh that was kind of the birth of it and where we got our unique niche and our fit.
Josh: Own It or Rent It
Opening those doors is ultimately about ownership. When an organization is forced to rely on managed services and opaque reporting, they are renting their strategy rather than owning it. High minimums and inflated rates function as structural barriers that prevent rapid testing and adjustment. Self-serve technology shifts the leverage back to the business, allowing leaders to run targeted campaigns without the friction of traditional agency overhead.
Having the technology, though, is only the first step. As platforms become more automated and performance-driven, the relationship between human judgment and algorithmic execution is shifting in ways that most leaders have not fully accounted for.
Where the Ad Dollar Goes
Chart
Where the ad dollar goes
Share of each $1.00 consumed by cost layer. Each dot represents one cent. Managed programmatic versus self-serve direct. Illustrative scenario based on published industry data.
Managed / Agency Programmatic — cost layers per $1.00
$0.30
DSP platform & SSP fees
$0.20
Agency management fee
$0.14
Measurement & tech overhead
$0.36
Reaches active media placement
Self-Serve Direct — cost layers per $1.00
$0.15
Platform fees & tools
$0.85
Reaches active media placement
ANA 2024: hidden programmatic costs reduce true media delivery to 36% of total ad spend for managed buyers. DSP markups on CTV alone exceed 100% of the publisher rate, per MediaPost data obtained by Gupta Media.
Source: City Shift Finance · ANA 2024 Programmatic Media Study · Gupta Media / MediaPost · Digiday
Illustrative scenario based on published industry data as of May 2026
As advertising becomes more data-driven and performance focused, what changes do you think business leaders are still underestimating?
Jeff: People, Tech, Process
So marketers and business leaders have a lot on their plate, but one of the things that's been a hot topic uh in this industry for years now and continues to be and will continue to be is the drive towards data-driven and performance focused information. And I think there's still a disconnect there. And I think the disconnect is actually the consistency flux be the consistency flux sorry between the reliance and putting in place the right technology and then also where the human component comes into play.
So when I say that I feel like some people will invest so heavily into technology and just accept whatever it says without really putting much human thought into it. which what I found is there's so many data points, so many different things and so many experiences that the human uh brain can actually come in assess and find golden nuggets and value in it instead of just saying hey this is what AI tells me. The other side of the coin is the underutilization of technology where it's just using the human brains or assumptions or things that worked in the past.
So essentially where I think that there's a miss and that there needs to be a bigger focus for most people is the combination and the balance between each of those things. And it starts with having the right technology in place in my opinion. Well, actually it starts with having the right people in place. That's a whole another story, but assuming you have the right people in place, you got to put the right technology in place.
And I stole a process called a sprint from software development. So sprint is a short limited amount of time where you hyperfocus on a specific project or task in order to just bang it out and get as much work done on it as possible. So when I do assessments of technology, I say, "Hey, what are we trying to find and what are our options that are out there?" And I'm going to give myself a deadline in order to work on this, but I'm also going to give myself a lot of time to work on it as well, too. So that way I can be very efficient with figuring these things out and I don't have to try to remember things over the course of a whole year as they pop up uh for me.
So I do a I recommend a technology sprint uh discovery to identify what technology makes the most sense for you and what are you going to adopt and use or continue to use. And then once you have the tools in place then you need to be able to put the process in place and this is what actually connects the humans with the technology.
So I have seen in different variations it really fail when people invest in technology but their people or they themselves aren't leveraging it to the best of their ability or at all. And a lot of that comes into play is because there's not like a process there's not a cadence in place for people to actually leverage the technology that's out there to get data driven and performance focused information.
So put a process in place, put a organizational uh structure in place that ensures in a timely manner that the technologies is being utilized, information is being reviewed and that uh you can also encourage saying hey while you're doing that think about it try to think about the information we have try to um encourage your people so that they need to be the ones that are really kind of identifying what the important KPIs are with the assistance of technology as well too.
And I think that that's where you find the happy medium of combining uh some of the pitfalls that are happening right now for understanding this type of data is making sure you have the right tools in place, the right process in place to understand those tools and that you encourage your people to think creatively and objectively when looking at this information so they can leverage it to their greatest purpose.
Josh: The Decision Layer
The tension Jeff describes between technology and human judgment is where modern execution either succeeds or fails. It is easy to assume that buying more advanced software or running more automated campaigns will automatically solve your customer acquisition problems. Technology without process is just expensive noise.
Looking across all three areas covered today, from the planning phase to the self-serve execution of geofencing, to the integration of data and human oversight, the core lesson is consistent. True efficiency requires structuring your operations so that your team can apply their judgment where it matters most.
A technology sprint is a valuable operational mechanism because it forces a focused evaluation. The tools you choose are only as good as the cadence you build around them. If your team is not reviewing the data, identifying the key performance indicators, and adjusting the strategy with creative intent, then the algorithm is simply spending your budget faster.
For leaders navigating this landscape, the challenge is to move away from comfortable vanity metrics like impressions and clicks, and focus instead on incremental business outcomes. You must build an internal decision layer that unifies your data, your tools, and your people.
Our thanks to Jeff Schwarz for joining us today and for a conversation that gives leaders a sharper lens on where their marketing capital is actually going.
Thank you for listening to the City Shift Finance podcast.
We will see you in the next episode.
Our Appreciation
We thank Jeff Swartz for sharing his perspective on advertising efficiency, customer acquisition, and the role of technology in modern marketing.
City Shift Finance podcast
Josh and City Shift Finance partners examine the financial conditions that determine enterprise performance.