Portrait of Stephen Tam

A Conversation with Stephen Tam

Retail Interview

AU Beauty Bazaar founder Stephen Tam, formerly in strategy roles at KPMG, MetLife and TransUnion, discusses pricing power, customer demand and the decisions behind building a seven-figure retailer.

City Shift Finance: Beauty products are unusually easy to compare online. When a customer can find the same product at several retailers within seconds, what still gives a retailer room to charge a different price?

Stephen Tam: Everyone likes a low price, and beauty makes comparison very easy, what surprised us is how much the intangibles still decide where people buy. Customers will often choose a retailer they trust and enjoy dealing with over one that is slightly cheaper.

At AU Beauty Bazaar, those intangibles are deliberate. We have strong customer service, and we don’t just deal in emails. Customers can message us directly on WhatsApp from our website, which most of our competitors don’t offer, and we call our customers from time to time. We ship very quickly, we run a good loyalty program, and we include nice free samples with every order. We also package every order carefully. Skincare is personal, and we want customers to feel their beauty products have been packed with love and care. None of that shows up in a price comparison, but all of it shows up in whether a customer comes back.

We learned early not to compete on price alone. Even as we’ve grown to a $3.4M annual run-rate, our focus has been on keeping a loyal customer base rather than winning every one-off order on price. A customer who has had a quick reply on WhatsApp, received their order fast and beautifully packed, with samples they actually wanted, is far less likely to switch for a dollar or two.

So the room to charge a different price comes from the total experience. The product may be identical across retailers, but the service, speed and relationship around it are not, and customers do value that difference, even if they wouldn’t describe it as a reason to pay more.

City Shift Finance: When you look across your assortment, which products require you to stay very close to competitors on price, and where do you have more freedom? What creates that difference?

Stephen Tam: The products where we have to stay very close to competitors are our bestsellers, which we call our high-moving brands. These are the products customers search for by name and compare across sites, so they get people in the door. We price them competitively and accept a thinner margin, because they bring in the traffic and the first order.

Sunscreen is a good example. Sunscreens move heavily in Australia, and our Beauty of Joseon sunscreen is one of our strongest sellers. Because it is so widely known and so easy to compare, it leaves us less margin than most of our range. We treat that as the cost of being a destination for the products people already want.

We have more freedom on products that are harder to compare. We private label some products, and we carry unique brands that not many retailers sell in the Australian market. Because a customer can’t find the same product at several sites within seconds, we can price those differently and earn a better margin.

What creates the difference is simple: comparability. The more famous and widely stocked a product is, the closer we have to stay to the market. The more distinctive a product is, through private labelling, exclusivity or being early to bring a brand into Australia, the more our pricing reflects our own value rather than a competitor’s price. A healthy business needs both types: the first brings customers in, the second pays for the business.

City Shift Finance: When your landed cost changes because of supplier pricing, freight, or currency movements, what determines whether you raise the customer price, accept a lower margin, or stop pushing that product?

Stephen Tam: In general, we pass cost increases on to customers. At the start, we absorbed cost increases to protect our prices, but over time we concluded that it’s better to pass them on. Absorbing every increase slowly erodes margin, and it doesn’t build the kind of loyalty that service and experience do.

We don’t change prices every week or with every shipment, because constant movement confuses customers and creates unnecessary work. Instead, we review prices on a monthly basis. That gives us a regular, disciplined point to reflect changes in supplier pricing, freight and currency, without reacting to every short-term fluctuation.

Shipping is a recent example. We contract Australia Post for delivery, and they raised their prices following the energy shock earlier this year. We raised our shipping prices in line with that increase rather than absorbing it, because shipping is a real cost of every order.

The decision to stop pushing a product is different, and it’s usually about demand rather than cost. In our industry, if a product’s demand is fading, a lower margin won’t save it. If demand is strong, customers will generally accept a reasonable price increase, especially when the rest of the offer, such as fast shipping, good service and gifts, stays strong.

So our rule of thumb is: review monthly, pass on genuine cost increases, and judge whether to keep backing a product on its demand, not on whether we can afford to discount it.

City Shift Finance: How do you distinguish between a customer responding to the price itself and responding to the total offer, including product availability, shipping, gifts, bundles, or trust in the retailer?

Stephen Tam: The clearest evidence we have is that customers often respond more strongly to the total offer than to the price itself.

Gifts with purchase are a good example. We offer gifts once an order reaches a minimum threshold, and we currently have three tiers of free gifts placed strategically. What we found is that giving good, fresh gifts that people actually want raises average order value. Customers add items to reach the next tier, not because any single product became cheaper, but because the overall offer became more attractive. We design those tiers carefully so the gift supports our margin rather than eroding it. Since our launch period in late 2024, our average order value has grown from $66 to $95.

Free shipping thresholds work the same way. Customers will often add to their basket to reach free shipping, which tells us the total cost and convenience of the order matters as much as the product price.

We also use site-wide discounts, sent through our emails from time to time when we need a pickup in sales, and for holiday sales. Comparing how customers respond to a straight discount versus a gift or shipping threshold helps us see what is really driving the purchase.

Trust and service sit underneath all of this. Customers can message us on WhatsApp, we ship quickly, and we run a loyalty program. When a customer keeps buying from us despite being able to find a lower price elsewhere, that is the clearest sign they are responding to the total offer, not just the price.

City Shift Finance: Have you had a product where you discovered customers were willing to pay more than you initially expected, or the reverse? What evidence told you that the original price was wrong?

Stephen Tam: Yes, both ways, and both taught us that demand matters more than the price tag.

When a product becomes very in demand or goes viral, we see strong momentum, to the point where customers are willing to pay a lot more than we initially expected. That has helped our margins over short periods. The evidence is straightforward: sales stay strong even at a higher price, and customers are actively seeking the product rather than comparing it. But we’ve learned to treat that as temporary. Once the virality fades, so does the willingness to pay a premium, and the price needs to come back to reality.

The reverse is just as important. Beauty has many fads and quick trends, and once a brand stops marketing, we can see it die quickly. We had one brand where customers were buying very strongly at the beginning of the year. By the end of the year, we were offering discounts of 50 percent and no one was buying.

That experience was a clear lesson that the original price wasn’t the problem. The demand had simply gone. A lower price can’t revive a product customers no longer want.

The evidence that tells us a price is wrong is how sales respond over time: whether demand holds at a higher price, or whether a discount actually moves stock. For us, the bigger risk is not pricing too high or too low on day one, but failing to notice when the trend behind a product has changed.

City Shift Finance: As AU Beauty Bazaar has expanded its assortment, has carrying more products strengthened your ability to price differently from competitors, or has it increased price competition because customers have more alternatives?

Stephen Tam: Yes. A large assortment has strengthened our ability to price differently, not weakened it.

I always tell our team that we are a supermarket. Customers come in for the eggs, milk and butter, which we price competitively. In our business, those are the high-moving brands and bestsellers like our Beauty of Joseon sunscreen. But once they are in the store, we can price more strongly on other things, the equivalent of chips and ice cream. For us, that means private label products and unique brands that few retailers carry in Australia.

A big range also matters to customers in its own right. Customers like a large assortment, much like Amazon, even when they don’t buy most of it. It signals that we are a serious destination, and it gives them a reason to start their search with us. Who likes going to a supermarket that only has a few things on the shelves?

It’s true that more products give customers more alternatives within our own store, but that is competition we are happy to have. If a customer chooses a different product from us, we still keep the sale. The bigger risk would be a narrow range that forces customers to go elsewhere for half of what they want, where they may then find everything.

The key is to be deliberate about which products play which role: the competitively priced staples that bring customers in, and the distinctive products where we can earn a stronger margin. Pasted markdown

Our Appreciation

Thank you to Stephen Tam for sharing their perspective.

This interview is part of City Shift Finance’s Executive Conversations, bringing operating and financial perspectives from leaders across the industries we serve.

Contact us

Create your account

Continue your analyses, email calculation records, and return to your work from one account.

Have an account?

Contact us

Contact us

Contact

Topics of Interest:

Sign up to download